Peer Review of Lukes Memoir

Luke-

Great work on the rough draft of your essay. Overall, I think it’s well done, and you use good detail in a lot of places. I think your main point is to illustrate that people need to get out and enjoy the outdoors now, because someday global warming/climate change could change that. It seemed like you were probably not remotely interested in going hiking but were pleasantly surprised with how much you enjoyed it. A couple lines that stuck out to me:
1. “But I was particularly interested in finishing up the main campaign of The Elder Scrolls: Skyrim, New Super Mario Bros. U, or anything else honestly.”
This one I just like because when I was on deployment we stopped in Italy for a day and we bought an Italian Xbox and bought Oblivion so I’m familiar with the Elder Scrolls series. It also gives the reader a sense of your reluctant mood to go on this hike.

2. “With the constant damaging of our environment due to deforestation, air pollution, and poor recycling practices, our day of reckoning may be sooner than we anticipate.”
I think this line kind of states your universal message. Get out and experience the outdoors because it might not always be there ect.

There are a few places where the detail was particularly good, for instance:
“Fresh smells of pine and dew from the rain the prior night invaded my nostrils, surprising my body. After the initial surprise, my body grew accustomed, and came to enjoy the tangible genuinity of this environment.”
I like these couple of lines because I can clearly imagine the sensation you get when you plunge into the woods and smell nothing but pine needles and thick fresh air. I also liked this bit about the cliff face:
“For about 30 yards in front of us was one slick sheet of marble white rock, approaching our impending doom – a cliff – at a 45 degree angle. Trees found their ways into the sheet like hair follicles, spread sporadically across the plane.”
This gives the reader a pretty good description of what you are facing. I liked the metaphor you used to describe the trees.

I think you could expand the details in a couple places however. After the initial slide on the ice you could explain some more about how the rest of the climb went in more detail. Especially the bit about Mt.Dickey. We could use some detail about how the second portion of the hike went. Were you exhausted? Did you barely make it? Some things like that could help.

Organizationally/structure wise I think the piece is good. The use of dialogue in the lead makes me interested to continue reading. The order of events is clear. I would ask what happened with your siblings? Were they just on the drive and not the hike? Not super important to the narrative but I figured id ask. I also like that you included (what I assume) is a picture of mount Welch/Dickey. I like that you put it towards the end of the piece, so you have a chance to describe the place before showing us exactly what it looks like.

I think you have a good start to a memoir here. Apart from a few wonky sentences there isn’t any major grammatical errors I can see. The best parts of this essay so far are your reflections towards the end. It gives good insight into your frame of mind.

Great start to the memoir. Polish it up a bit and you’re in good shape. Good luck!

Reading Journal # 1

Op-Ed: The Silent Generation of the Forgotten War

The main point of this article is to illustrate some of the reasons why the Korean war is referred to as the “forgotten” war. The author poses several statistics about the number of combatants killed in wars before and after Korea, saying that 1 in 10 combatants were killed in the war. Several organizations such as the VFW did not accept these veterans into their organizations because Truman labeled the war a “Police action”. The author also talks about two of his friends that were POW’s during the war and their struggles with PTSD.

I found it interesting that a higher percentage of combatants were killed In Korea than in WWII and Vietnam. The Korean War also had a higher number of POW’s kill in captivity.

I admired the way the author talked about his daughter asking him years later as an adult about his service.

“My answer was, “No one ever asked, and no one was interested in listening.”

 

 

Brass and Skittles (memoir rough draft)

Brass and Skittles

I saw more profound things in the world from ages eighteen to twenty-two than any other point in my life. I watched Stanley Kubrick’s Full-Metal Jacket at far too young an age. R Lee Ermey’s twenty-minute expletive laden rant was enough to get me to sign the papers. I enlisted in the Marine Corps right after high school and found myself on the yellow foot prints of Paris island, South Carolina. Three months grueling training and I became a Marine. The experience merits a story in its own right, but what stays with me more clearly years later, is what I saw in Africa while deployed.

I deployed in 2011 on what’s called a MEU (Marine Expeditionary Unit, pronounced “M-You”) to assist the people of Libya as they over threw Muammar Gaddafi. As a Marine, this means a lot of sitting in a muggy well-deck of a Navy ship, waiting to be pointed in a direction and told what to destroy. What was scheduled to be a 6-month deployment, turned into a year long one, bouncing from one Mediterranean country and port to the next all in support of the no-fly zone the US imposed.

Marines on board a ship don’t have much to do, other than worry about the Navy not hitting a mine. This is no Carnival cruise with our own state rooms however. We all lived in what’s called the berthing. Narrow rooms with coffin racks stacked 3 high, and low hanging pipes jutting in and out of everywhere. Privacy is soon a distant memory. Air circulation was poor, so smells lingered. Not exactly 5-star accommodations. Needless to say, when your trapped in an environment like that for months on end you lose a bit of your sanity. About halfway through our deployment we got a little respite from the bowels of the ship. We learned from command that the Marines would be doing a training exercise in Djibouti Africa for a month.

Djibouti? Never heard of it. Is it on dry land? Check. Is it off of this ship? Check. What are we waiting for?

We ended up flying off the ship on helicopters to reach the training area. My first impression looking out of the helicopter was basically a shoulder shrug. It’s a desert country sparsely populated. But not desert like you would think of the Sahara; more mountainous and rockier desert. No huge cities or infrastructure. Our base camp was literally concertina wire spread around a football sized area in the middle of a clearing. No man-made structures for miles. We spent the day setting up our camp, checking our gear, and going over the plan of attack for the following morning. We slept in sleeping bags on the ground under the stars.

One thing was very apparent when we woke up; we had guests. All along the outside of our C-wire was indigenous people hanging about. Men, women, and children all apparently waiting for us. All of them were dark skinned, and looked extremely impoverished. Their clothes all looked like thin patch work quilts sewn together haphazardly. The men and women were trying to barter for food, while the kids ran around playing hoop rolling. What we soon found out is that the whole community based its entire existence off collecting the brass casings left behind from various training exercises and reselling the metal.

This is not an unusual practice. Gun ranges the world over collect empty brass casings and sell them. But its more of an afterthought, something you do at the end of the month for spare change. What these people were doing was far different. Picture your average military style firing line. Straight line with marked positions every 3 or 4 feet with spots for marksman to fire from. The brass usually just collects in piles a few feet away where it is ejected, and picked up later. Now let’s picture it Djibouti style. Same straight line with positions, except we have kids as young as 10 jockeying for position to catch the brass as it flies out of your rifle. And when I say jockeying, I mean fighting tooth and nail to get the brass first. Not only is this unorthodox, its downright dangerous to have people screwing around on a live fire range.

I remember thinking afterwards how bizarre it was for someone to treat what I associated as trash, as a treasure worth fighting over. Those tiny bits of metal that probably make him two cents a pound could be turned into bread on his family’s table at night. Each pull of the trigger contributing in a small way to his well-being. It makes you reevaluate your own circumstances. Is my life difficult as a Marine? Sure. Do I have to fight for a meal at the end of the day?

A few days later I saw something else I’ve never been able to really quantify. We were all sitting around eating our dinner on top of our packs. Dinner was a plastic bag meal-ready-to-eat. If memory serves me it was a particularly disgusting number entitled “Dehydrated Pork Patty”. After taking a sip of my “Powdered Drink Mix, Fruit” I heard some Marines laughing raucously. Me and a couple members of my platoon walked over to see what was happening. Some guys were throwing candy to the kids over the barrier. But this wasn’t your Band of Brothers moment when a paratrooper hands a boy a bar of chocolate after liberating France. This was being done for sadistic amusement.

The Kids were beating each other over individual skittles. Not a whole bag, just the couple skittles the guys were throwing over the C-wire. While I don’t condone what was being done, I can’t be too hard on my colleagues. Everyone copes with the misery that is the Corps in different ways. The kids fighting each other was bad, but it wasn’t over yet. The adult individuals who had been a good distance away seemed to finally realize the Americans were throwing food over the wire. And that’s when I saw the strangest thing of my life. An obviously pregnant woman sprinting towards the group of kids screaming her head off. At first, I thought it was because she didn’t want the kids taking food from us, but then I realized it was because she wanted the food for herself. When she reached the group, she kicked a small boy full in the chest like a spartan and took the one skittle he had been about to eat. Most of the people around me laughed, but still more of us found it disturbing.

I’m not sure why I remember the event so clearly nearly 5 years later. Sometimes I think it was the savage pleasure derived from some of the people throwing the food that sticks with me. At other times I think it serves as a reminder to me that circumstances are different the world over. The comfortable lives most people live in the United States are far removed from a no-where country like Djibouti. I saw firsthand what real desperation and poverty looks like.

4 Sentences and Scene

  • My hometown was a place I felt free and safe.
  • Laci was a girl who’s usual hair style was a pink mohawk.
  • Mr.Brown grades his students papers with an iron fist, no other teacher comes close to achieving.
  • The room had four walls painted slate grey with no windows.

 

The slow patter of rain drops on the canvas became more distinct as the fog of sleep washed away. As he stirs from sleep, the smell of the nylon sleeping bag comes across his nose. Far more pressing than the smell of nylon, is the immediate pain in his back from sleeping on the hard earth. He tries to stretch out, but is impeded by the small dimensions of the tent. While the man fumbles for his clothes in the near-dark tent, the pace of the rain quickens. It will not be ideal weather for the camping trip this morning.

 

Memoir Sample

In “The Ultimate Sacrifice” Major Peter Godfrin describes to us why he wears a bracelet with one of his soldiers name on it. In July 2004 Sgt Christopher Wagener was killed when his vehicle hit a landmine in Iraq. The short memoir describes the immediate aftermath. The Major had experienced fellow soldiers dying under his command but this one was different. It was difficult for him to pinpoint why this death effected him so much more deeply than those previous. The major comments that there are rules for processing the death of a soldier but not training on processing the emotional tole it takes on fellow comrades. The death of this young sergeant made peter realize what making a true sacrifice for the country means.

I chose this memoir because I can directly relate to the story.  Although a shorter piece, it hits the right marks on what it means to deal with the emotional trauma that ensues in a unit after a death. As far as ideas for my own memoir, I think its a good example of how short poignant writing can be effective. The author doesn’t tell us much about the sgt, but you care about the fact he was killed. I also like that it ended by saying he was entering his fourth tour of service. Although he will never forget Christopher Wagener, he continues to serve his country.

The universal message running through this memoir is that it is important to never forget the sacrifices young people make in the armed services. While difficult to deal with emotionally , we can’t let an ultimate sacrifice be forgotten. The Major wears the name right on his wrist as a constant reminder of what happened to Chris. Its a story that most veterans can relate to who served during war times. Young people who have barely scratched the surface of life, are taken from us far too early, leaving behind grieving families and friends. By wearing the name proudly on his wrist he is letting everyone know that Chris didn’t give his life in vain; that the major will continue the fight. 

Myself as a Writer

Writing for me has always been something I don’t actively seek out, nor shy away from. I don’t mind taking a prompt and just running with it with little to no prep-work(something I realize needs to change). I find I generally can get my point across but usually in a more clinical way rather than an “artist painting a canvas”. Admittedly, I have had few occasions to do so since high school. Although a storied institution shrouded in mystic, The Marine Corps does not pride itself on written composition.  I’ve had little reason to stretch these muscles for a while, so bare with me.

After reading Ten Ways To Think About Writing, I can certainly relate to some of the points made therein. The whole concept of the cookie-cutter essay was definitely drilled into my head in High school, and I find it difficult to abandon even now. The majority of the opening points made by the author(E. Shelley Reid), tally with what I was taught in high school. Never starting a sentence with “but”, always have a thesis with three points, conclusion paragraph to restate the thesis, are just some of the many maxims of high school writing I remember. It’s almost painful to even write in the first person and use “I”; as its college I suppose its worth the risk. I think it will be interesting going foreword in the class to start experimenting with new styles of writing and expand my own knowledge of the writing process.

Classmate Snap Shot

Brandon at his High School Graduation 

 

Brandon is at his high school graduation in Wareham. He is sitting at a table in the cafeteria with his graduating class getting ready for the ceremony. Everyone in the cafeteria is in cap and gown and there is a light buzz of idle chatter. Eventually everyone stands up and forms two long lines and marches in precession to the field for the ceremony. The valedictorian and other noteworthy individuals give speeches that most people aren’t paying attention to. After the speeches and the reading of names, the students all throw their caps in the air. Brandon loses his cap and can’t find it. Partying soon commences afterwards.